The New Saints took a 3-0 lead inside thirty minutes, with a penalty from Declan McManus, a super strike from Danny Davies and a Josh Daniels header.
Newtown pulled a goal back, courtesy of ex-Saint, Louis Robles and that was the score at the break.
When the visitors were awarded a penalty in the second-half, it looked like groundhog day was on the cards.
Three days earlier, a comfortable 3-0 lead against Flint Town United became a not-so-cosy 3-2 as the Silkmen hit back.